« Would You Report Paid Links? | Main | Five Reasons Why I Like To Blog »

April 16, 2007

Newsvine Beats Digg To Punch

By Li Evans

Looks like Newsvine's users beat Digg's users in promoting the tragic mass shooting at Virginia Tech to the front page.  It was just about 1 p.m., and I was just finishing up lunch when I decided to take a gander at how the social news sites were handling this story.  I decided this was probably pretty popular since MSNBC's servers were taxed and when you could get through they reported no press were allowed into the campus.

To my surprise it was Newsvine that had the story already as the most active out on their front page.  Digg, for all its fame around "fast" news, didn't have it on the first two pages.  Netscape & Reddit were both minus the story as well at the time of this posting either.  Below is some screen captures.

Newsvineshootingfrontpage
Diggshootingfrontpage_2

Netscapeshootingfrontpage
Redditshootingfrontpage

Social news is fast - but it isn't always Digg that's the fastest!

update/clarification: this post was only meant to show the comparison among the social news sites, not social news as a substitute for main stream media, that would just be plain silly.  Also, as noted by Vicki (which I should have pointed out more clearly) it was actually Killfile's story that made it to the front page first, it's just that the AP story was more prominent.  Killfile's story about the VT incident is right below the AP Story with the picture.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfb1a53ef00d8341bfb2e53ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Newsvine Beats Digg To Punch:

» The tragedy at Virginia Tech from Clicked
When the Virginia Tech shooting story was breaking I was tinkering with Twitter tools to see if I could... [Read More]

» Newsvine Beats Digg To Punch from Search Marketing Gurus | Search Marketing Tips, Advice, Strategies Tactics From Internet Marketing Professionals from blackrimglasses.com
Newsvine Beats Digg To Punch from Search Marketing Gurus | Search Marketing Tips, Advice, Strategies Tactics From Internet Marketing Professionals: Im not surprised. Digg has become nearly irrelevant as of late. Such is the wisdom... [Read More]

» The Importance of MetaJournalism, Editorial Control in Social News from Pronet Advertising
A piece of commentary by Li Evans, pointing out that Newsvine beat Digg in reporting the VA Tech shooting made the rounds yesterday. While [Read More]

Comments

Your screenshot of Digg is only for the Technology subsection.

Newsvine got the story early because user generated content is only half their content; they also have a full Associated Press feed.

Carl

Muhammad - Good catch! :) I was surfing all around Digg at that time to see if it was anywhere I checked out all the tabs to see if I could find if it was popular anywhere (to be fair), and I couldn't find it. I must've thought I was on the home page when I grabbed the screenshot - apologies about that. Still Newsvine had it to their front page first. :)


Carl - yes, they do get their news that way, and that is the first thing I noticed. However the activity on the story at the time I was looking was incredibly more than what was on Digg at the time, and thus why it was on their front page.

I wouldn't have posted this if it was just their feed of the associated press story. :)

fyi, the VT story was broken on Newsvine before the AP feed appeared, by user Killfile, who was on campus at the time. That story was active on the front page for quite a while before the AP story was so prominently featured, as you show in your screen cap.

http://killfile.newsvine.com/_news/2007/04/16/666369-shootings-on-virginia-techs-campus-at-least-33-dead

Thanks!

The comments to this entry are closed.

Get SMG Today - Free!

Get SMG by RSS What Is RSS?
Get Search Marketing Gurus Today via RSS! Add to Google Reader or Homepage
Add to netvibes
Get SMG in Your Bloglines
Get SMG in Your NewsGator Online

Get SMG by E-Mail
Subscribe to SMG via Email
Enter your email address:


Delivered by FeedBurner

SMG Conversations

If You Like SMG Favorite Us on Technorati!
Add to Technorati Favorites
If You Like What SMG Has To Say, Joins Us At These Places!
Subscribe on YouTube to SMG's Videos
follow Li on Twitter
Follow Li on FriendFeed




Copyright 2006, 2007, 2008 SearchMarketingGurus.com